Save The Jail.org

> Home

> Editorials

> News & Schedules

> JCPASH

> Issues & Chronology

> Organizations Against Demolition

> Supreme Court's Ruling

> Justice McGraw's Opinion

> The Snyder Amendment

> History of Treason Trials

> Photographs

> Books Available

> How Can I Help?

> Contact Us

> Comments



News is posted by date commencing with the launch of this site. For a survey of events and issues prior to February 2003 go to "Issues and Chronology. "

03/15/03

A rally and news conference in support of saving the historic Jefferson County jail took place today at the Old Opera House and in front of the jail in Charles Town. Among the organizations represented were the National Trust for Historic Preservation, The West Virginia Preservation Alliance, the United Mine Workers of America, and the West Virginia Labor History Association.

The National Trust released an open letter to the citizens of Charles Town and Jefferson County, West Virginia. In this letter, the Trust released the findings of an on-site evaluation of the jail made by a team of architects led by George Siekkinen, Senior Architect of the National Trust. This study concluded that the historic jail is worthy of preservation, that it is structurally sound, and that it would be more cost effective to renovate the jail as opposed to razing it and building new. The study estimates that renovation would save the county taxpayers between $702,000 and $834,000 over the cost of new construction. These findings were mirrored in a report issued by the West Virginia Preservation Alliance whose own experts determined that the building is structurally solid and presents a prime candidate for rehabilitation. This study notes that many other buildings in West Virginia in much worse condition have been successfully restored.

The United Mine Workers of America and the West Virginia Labor History Association announced their support for the creation of a museum dedicated to telling the story of coal mining, labor heritage, and the treason trials. Discussions are already underway among interested parties including individuals from both organizations, local historians, and scholars and authors who have studied the mine wars and treason trials. Preliminary work has begun on establishing a non-profit foundation for the purpose of raising funds and building collections in order to establish just such a museum. It is the hope of these individuals and the goal of this foundation to lease or otherwise secure space in a renovated jail for this purpose.

If you would like to read these press releases in their entirety, please go to "Organizations Against Demolition."


03/07/03

A hearing has been set concerning the historic Jefferson County jail for 1:00 pm, Monday, March 31 in the Circuit Court at the Jefferson Court Courthouse. The hearing was requested by Jefferson County Prosecutor Michael Thompson who will seek to have the injunction against demolition of the jail lifted. Apparently Thompson will argue that the recent vote by the county commission to raze the jail will allow them to bypass an historic review. He will make this argument despite a recent 5-0 WV Supreme Court ruling that the original law requiring the review must be followed. Plaintiff's attorney Tom Michaels will likely argue that the commission is making the same ex poste facto argument that they recently lost before the Supreme Court.


02/07/03

In a meeting described as "tense" by a local newspaper, and over the strenuous objections of Commissioners Greg Corliss and Rusty Morgan, the Jefferson County Commission voted last night 3-2 to make another attempt to demolish the old historic jail. In late December the WV Supreme Court of Appeals reaffirmed its earlier 5-0 decision to reinstate an injunction against demolition pending the completion of an historic survey. Nevertheless, Commission President Jane Tabb offered a motion to demolish the jail, and to direct Prosecuting Attorney Mike Thompson to seek to have the injunction lifted. The motion passed with Commissioners Al Hooper and James Knode joining Tabb.

The vote was preceded by a long debate among the commissioners over the proper course of action. Morgan and Corliss argued that the issue should be tabled. "We need a lot more information to make this important decision," Morgan said. He argued that the commission needs to develop a long range plan and not simply react to current needs. Noting that there is enough space on the Courthouse block to build a new 80,000 square foot judicial center two times over without touching the jail, he questioned why the commission should act without due consideration. Corliss agreed that there is no compelling reason for undue haste in making any decisions and also requested more time to properly study options. However Commissioner Hooper questioned how the jail could be historic as it is only 85 years old and Knode characterized it as "worthless." The issue now appears headed back to court.

To see a response by JCPASH, go to " issues"


02/06/03

According to an article in the Martinsburg Journal, Bill Theriault of the Jefferson County Landmarks Commission criticized the County's new Comprehensive plan. Theriault directed his criticism toward the Planning and Zoning Commission noting that in the two years since the Landmarks Commission had delivered its proposed historic preservation section to the Planning Commission, there had been "no dialogue" between the parties.

"This is very disappointing to us" he said of the plan which reduced the Landmarks Commission's proposal from 14 pages to only one, observing also that the Comprehensive Plan does not even mention the 2-year struggle to save the historic Jefferson County Jail. Among the County's deficiencies, Theriault cited the lack of a reliable survey of the county's historic sites and poor stewardship of county-owned historic structures.


02/05/03

The Martinsburg Journal reports that consultants with the West Virginia Courthouse Improvement Authority have recommended that the Jefferson County jail be torn down. However, as noted by County Circuit Clerk Patricia Noland, the authority does not consider "social concerns", i.e. historic and cultural value. Rather the authority limits itself to questions of function and efficiency. (To see a pointed criticism of the authority, see Justice McGraw's opinion.)

Noland also notes that the authority recommended $15.2 million worth of improvements to downtown Jefferson County buildings. Logically, the majority of that sum would be spent on the new judicial center. One has to imagine that rehabilitating the jail even if it required some expansion would cost far less.

It is interesting to note that while certain commissioners will make much of the authorities recommendations, these same commissioners have refused to even acknowledge the recommendations of the National Trust, the Department of Interior / the National Park Service, and the West Virginia Division of Culture and History.


02/01/03

By a 3-2 vote the Jefferson County Commission voted yesterday to delay by at least a week discussion on demolition of the old jail. Commissioners Rusty Morgan, Greg Corliss, and James Knode voted to table the issue while Commissioners Jane Tabb and Al Hooper opposed. Corliss reasoned that "I don't see there is any hurry to make any decision. I don't think we should be pushed on something we might not want to do,"

A representative from the state Courthouse Facility Improvement Authority, which has recommended that the old jail be demolished, may appear before the commission in the future. On December 27 the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals reaffirmed 5-0 its earlier decision staying an injunction against demolition pending an historic review.

Justice Warren McGraw wrote a concurring opinion in which he warned that the Improvement Authority represented a real threat to the State's historic courthouses especially in light of the Snyder Amendment which he observed gutted West Virginia's preservation statutes. For a complete review of Justice McGraw's opinion go to the "Justice McGraw's Opinion."

  SaveTheJail.org - © 2003 SteveInc - All rights reserved.